MSPB Law Blog

By John V. Berry, Esq., www.berrylegal.com

What is a Conduct Unbecoming Charge?

Conduct Unbecoming cases at the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB) are known to involve the most generalized form of misconduct. In other words, the charge can cover a number of different types of offenses. It is the most common charge used when no others specifically apply.  It is important to understand the nature of this type of charge when an employee is defending against this type of charge at the MSPB or during proposed discipline.  I have included some samples of conduct unbecoming charges to give a sense of how broad these types of charges can be.  

Sample Charges of Conduct Unbecoming

The following are some examples of conduct unbecoming charges that might be lodged against a federal employee:

1. On November 14, 2017, you engaged in conduct unbecoming when you began to argue with co-workers about an assignment that was overdue. You then approached your supervisor, Jim Jones, and told him “I am done here. You can take this assignment and shove it.” Your disrespectful attitude and profanity in the workplace is unacceptable and you.

2. On July 14, 2018, you engaged in conduct unbecoming when you informed others in the office that you were the recipient of the Purple Heart award for military service, when in fact you never served in the military. Your misconduct reflected poorly on the agency.

3. On October 5, 2017 and October 8, 2017, you engaged in conduct unbecoming when you claimed that you worked your full schedule during those two days. After an investigation, it was discovered that you did not work the two days in question, had not been in the office and falsely claimed time for hours not actually worked.

4. On November 5, 2017, you engaged in conduct unbecoming when you shoplifted a television from a local electronics store. You were subsequently caught for the theft, charged and convicted of criminal theft. 

Elements Needed to Prove Conduct Unbecoming

A conduct unbecoming charge is proven by demonstrating that the employee committed the general misconduct alleged. In order to prove a charge of conduct unbecoming at the MSPB an agency needs to be able to do so by a preponderance of the evidence. The agency will need to establish that the employee (1)  committed the misconduct as alleged and (2) that the conduct was improper or that it detracted from the federal employee’s character or reputation. Crouse v. Dept’ of Treas., 75 MSPR 57 (1997).

Defenses to Conduct Unbecoming Charges

There are a number of different types of methods of defense for general conduct unbecoming charges. The first is to challenge the actual facts alleged. If the facts can be disputed, the charge itself can potentially be defeated. Another potential avenue for challenging a conduct unbecoming charge is to argue that the charge was too vague and thus did not provide a legitimate opportunity to respond. Mason v. Dep't of Navy, 70 MSPR 584 (1996). Other defenses may involve the fact that other employees have engaged in similar conduct but not been charged with discipline. Other potential arguments, including issues where the same conduct has been charged multiple times may be challenged through the merger doctrine (the concept that the same conduct cannot be charged multiple times in the same manner). The number of potential defenses to a conduct unbecoming charge are varied and require the assistance of a attorney knowledgeable in federal employment law to determine the best strategy.  

Conclusion

In sum, when facing a conduct unbecoming charge it is very important to retain legal counsel familiar with the MSPB. Our law firm represents federal employees before the MSPB and can be contacted at www.berrylegal.com or by telephone at (703) 668-0070. Our Facebook page is located here.